Civics & Coffee: A History Podcast is now on YouTube!
Nov. 17, 2026

Global Ambitions: Mark Kawar on America, But Bigger

Global Ambitions: Mark Kawar on America, But Bigger
Global Ambitions: Mark Kawar on America, But Bigger
Civics & Coffee
Global Ambitions: Mark Kawar on America, But Bigger

When the current administration announced its interest in acquiring Greenland, several people were left wondering why - exactly - would the United States try to remake borders in the twenty-first century? Author Mark Kawar explains that this announcement is actually part of a long, complex history of attempted U.S. territorial expansion. Join me as I welcome Mark to discuss his book America, But Bigger.

In our conversation we cover:

  • The varied motivations behind annexation attempts
  • Some of the unexpected territories like the Galapagos Islands
  • The significance of guano in the 19th century
  • How William Seward was a super aggressive annexationist

To learn more about Mark check out his website:

https://americabutbigger.com/

BUY THE BOOK: America, But Bigger

Want Me To Cover a Topic?

Reach Out!

Want More Civics & Coffee?

Sign Up for the Substack

Join the Patreon Coffee Club

Make Sure We Are Connected:

Instagram

BlueSky

Threads

Love Civics & Coffee?

Review on Apple

Rate on Spotify

Disclaimer: Links to books are affiliate links. Each purchase helps support great historical scholarship, independent book stores, and the podcast!

Support the show

SPEAKER_00

Welcome to Civics and Coffee, a history podcast. The show all about United States history. Delivered to you and the time it takes to enjoy your morning cup of coffee. I'm your host, Alicia, a historian trained in United States history with a passion for telling both the known and unknown parts of America's past. So grab your coffee and get ready for some bite-sized history. Hey peeps, welcome back. The president made headlines earlier this year when he announced his desire to acquire Greenland. While many were surprised by this announcement, my guest this week understood that there was a long history of US attempts at expansion. So much so that he wrote a book about it. I hope you all enjoy the conversation. Welcome everyone. Joining me today is Mark Kawar. He's a former newspaper reporter and media executive whose writing focuses on American history and institutions. He is the author of America But Bigger, a history of American territorial expansion, which will be the focus of our conversation today. Welcome, Mark. Glad to be here. So let's dive right on in. You frame your book as more of a narrative history. And I'm curious, what prompted that approach?

SPEAKER_01

So before the book was a book, the book was a map. Go back in time to 2019 when Donald Trump first started talking about buying Greenland. And I was as shocked as most Americans. But I've always been a bit of a history and geography nerd, so I knew that this was not the first time the U.S. has tried to acquire Greenland. But I thought it would be interesting to make a map and post it to social media what the U.S. would look like with Greenland. But then I thought, well, wouldn't it be an interesting question to answer of what other places could have become part of the US? And I knew that there had been attempts to conquer Canada and buy Cuba, and the US had been in the Philippines and then left. And the question evolved to how far could America's borders have stretched? But I couldn't post anything to social media because I kept doing more research and I kept learning about more annexation targets. And I realized how much history there was and how fascinating it was. And fast forward a couple of years, and I realized that I'd written a book. So just little by little, the book accumulated from more and more stories, and one led to another, and I kept going down more and more rabbit holes. And I think the result is just completely fascinating. And I learned so much writing it, and I think that readers will as well. Places like Taiwan and the island of Borneo and the Galapagos Islands have all been in America's sites at one time or another.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

Well, and can you talk a little bit about the early attempts at annexing territory? You know, this covers kind of a long spans of time. So how did the colonies and then the what turned into the nascent United States attempt to acquire territory to the North Aaron?

SPEAKER_01

So one of the themes running throughout the book is that there's nothing inevitable about America's borders. So the the British and other European colonists came to the Western Hemisphere and immediately they started spreading out. But I would trace the origins of American expansionism to 1774. And that's when the first Continental Congress was meeting, and it included representatives of 12 colonies, not 13. And they wanted to expand their revolutionary union. They wanted to bring in more British North American colonies. So they sent out letters to East Florida and West Florida and Georgia and Quebec and Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland. And they were successful in one of these efforts, and Georgia joined them the next year as the 13th colony. So that was sort of America's first expansion from 12 to 13 colonies. But they still wanted, uh they still wanted more. They were really excited about these ideas of liberty and thought that the British crown was oppressing not just them, but its other colonies. So they especially pressed for Quebec to join the Union. It was the largest colony in British North America outside of these 13, and it was really the gateway to the rest of the North. If Quebec had joined them, it would have been pretty hard for Prince Edward Island and Nova Scotia and the rest of them to stay out. So they sent more letters to Quebec and didn't get a response. And then in 1775, Congress told its Northern Army in New York to proceed into Canada if practicable and if it would not be disagreeable to the Canadians. So a little bit vague. The army wasn't sure if it was going to move north or not. But then they saw that the British were massing troops and ships on Lake Champlain and going to move south into New York. So they decided to uh to go into Canada. It wasn't originally a mission of conquest, it was almost a defensive action. But they had some early successes. They quickly captured Montreal with not a lot of fighting. And then they kept going. And they chased the British governor up to Quebec City, and it was really a near thing. If certain circumstances had gone differently, if they had caught him along the way, if they had uh been able to take the city quickly. That was really the last bastion of British resistance in what is today Canada. And it's not too much of a stretch to think that if Quebec City had fallen, the rest of those colonies that became Canada could have fallen as well, and today America would have a northern half instead of a northern border. But the Siege of Quebec was not successful. There was an attack on New Year's Eve, 1775, in a snowstorm. They were driven, Americans were driven back, they besieged the city, British reinforcements arrived, there were some more battles, but eventually they crossed back into New York and arrived at their base on July 1st, 1776, just three days before the Declaration of Independence. And so the United States declared its independence 250 years ago with 13 states, not 14.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

Well, and I think, you know, many Americans who know their history hopefully are would be quite aware of the attempts to annex and invade Canada. But as you mentioned, right, America's eyes have been global in in scope in terms of trying to expand. And as the book demonstrates, the U.S. tried to go throughout the entire world. So were there any unexpected places you found while putting your research together?

SPEAKER_01

So many fascinating stories, but one I whip that Americans were more aware of was the story of the Galapagos Islands. We think of them today with Charles Darwin and his theory of evolution and the amazing wildlife in the Galapagos. But there was a time when they very nearly became part of the United States. So Ecuador claimed the Galapagos in the 1830s, but it didn't really do much with them. It it made a couple of attempts to settle them, but it's pretty harsh conditions there. So there were times when there was a small population, they were unpopulated. The U.S. got interested in the Galapagos in the 1850s when it appeared that there were large deposits of valuable guano fertilizer there. And the U.S. made an offer to buy the Galapagos from Ecuador, but then it withdrew it when it realized that actually there wasn't much guano there at all. For the rest of the 19th and into the 20th century, Ecuador and the U.S. were doing this sort of back and forth dance. And there were times when Ecuador was trying to sell the Galapagos, but the U.S. were wasn't interested in buying them, and times when the U.S. wanted to buy, but Ecuador wasn't interested in selling. And so there was a willing buyer and there was a willing seller, just never at the same time. So that tells you how close the U.S. came to acquiring the Galapagos. The closest call was in 1910, when the two sides actually reached a deal and came up with a price, but then they just couldn't quite agree on the terms. The U.S. wanted to put some restrictions on how Ecuador was going to use this money. Ecuador would accept some restrictions, but didn't exactly want what the U.S. was offering, and the whole thing fell apart. This would have been a 99-year lease, so not a complete permanent annexation, but the Galapagos essentially would have become part of the United States, and it would have been a valuable Pacific outpost on the Western approach to the Panama Canal, just before the Panama Canal opened. That's why the U.S. was interested. So it came very close, and the U.S. continued its interest in the Galapagos up through World War II, but never quite reached a deal with Ecuador.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

And then you mentioned in your response guano, which I was woefully uninformed about. So can you talk about how did the desire for guano lead to moves at annexation?

SPEAKER_01

So for listeners who don't know, guano is bird excrement, and it builds up on tropical islands, and it's an excellent agricultural fertilizer. You put it on a field and it can really increase the crop yields. And guano was basically the oil of the 19th century. It was this valuable resource that's in remote and hard-to-get to places, and there was sort of a global scramble for guano, the way that there in the 20th century there was a scramble for oil. America's most ambitious annexationist, William Seward, who later became Secretary of State, introduced the Guano Islands Act in 1856, which was his solution for how the U.S. was going to meet its guano needs. And the act said that any American, not just a government official, but private citizens, if they found an island anywhere in the world that was unclaimed by another country and contained guano, they could make a claim, bring it back to the State Department, and if it accepted it, the island would appertain to the United States. Now, originally it was a little unclear what that meant, but later court rulings decided that meant the U.S. was annexing it. So there ended up being a hundred accept a hundred or so accepted claims, and many more that either weren't accepted or the paperwork just got lost. There was, there's, it's really unclear during this era which islands were part of the United States and which weren't, because the record keeping wasn't great. So there were claims all around the world. Some of the more tenuous ones go all the way into like Brazilian islands in the South Atlantic, islands in the Indian Ocean off of Africa's coast, there's one off of Australia. But then the more firm claims, some of them today are part of Japan, the Pacific Nation of Kiribati, Mexico, Jamaica. What's interesting is that in addition to the status of a lot of these islands being a bit ambiguous and which ones were part of the U.S. and which ones weren't, there wasn't really a formal process at the time for giving up islands that the U.S. wasn't interested in. So some of them just sort of slipped away. Eight of these islands are still part of the U.S. today, but others, the U.S. just sort of lost interest and let them go once the once the guano ran out. And so there are islands around the world today that are part of other countries that at one point may have been part of the US and then just sort of drifted off.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

That was a fascinating part of the of the book. So if for no other reason, I think people should pick up the book and read about that fascinating history. But your book also connects the past to the present. And, you know, we're talking about Greenland. So the US has made prior attempts to annex Greenland, as we've mentioned. So can you talk a bit about these and the motivations behind them?

SPEAKER_01

So there's a lot that's attractive about Greenland that Donald Trump is talking about today. And a lot of these same things were attractive to the United States in the 19th century, too. Greenland is very strategically located. It's a great outpost in the North Atlantic. It's on the way between the U.S. and Europe. It's got natural resources, minerals, fish. So the first American to get seriously interested in Greenland was Secretary of State William Seward after the Civil War. A lot of Americans will remember him as the man who uh led the acquisition of Alaska. And so he was America's most ambitious annexationist. And after the purchase of Alaska, his next main target was the Danish West Indies. These islands are today the U.S. Virgin Islands. And he wanted an American outpost in the Caribbean. So he was negotiating with Denmark for these islands in the Caribbean. And one of his political allies, another ambitious annexationist, said, Why don't we expand these negotiations? If you're already talking with Denmark about the Danish West Indies, see if they'll throw in Greenland and Iceland as well. And Seward was interested in this idea. So we had the State Department commission a report, and it outlined a lot of these strategic reasons that I mentioned earlier. It also said that it would be good to acquire Greenland because you've got Alaska to the west, you've got Greenland to the east, this will surround Canada, and then we can annex Canada next. So the report recommended annexing Greenland and Iceland, but the whole thing fell apart because Seward's boss, President Andrew Johnson, was feuding with Congress, and Congress didn't want to give him a foreign policy win. It basically said, cool it with the territorial ambitions. You've just bought Alaska, no more, and they ended up impeaching Johnson. So the the deal for Greenland and Iceland and also the Danish West Indies all fell apart. But the U.S. never lost its interest in Greenland. There were Americans exploring Greenland throughout the 19th and into the 20th century, and some of them were staking claims. And it was a little unclear in the early 20th century exactly what Greenland's shape was. No one had really mapped the whole thing. And did Denmark really own the entire island or just the areas where it had settlements? So explorer Robert Perry, who is credited as the first person to reach the North Pole, he extensively explored northern Greenland, including areas that Denmark had never explored. He planted the U.S. flag there and made a claim to northern Greenland on America's behalf. There was also a diplomat at the time who tried to engineer a land swap for Greenland with Denmark. But that era fell apart because Woodrow Wilson succeeded where Seward had failed, and he did reach an agreement to buy the Danish West Indies. And as part of that deal, Denmark insisted that the U.S. give up any claims that it might have had to Greenland. So it traded away rights in Greenland to get these more strategic islands near the Panama Canal. The third U.S. attempt on Greenland was during World War II, when Germany conquered Denmark and the U.S. moved into Greenland to protect it and make sure that the Germans didn't move into Greenland as well. And after the war, they wanted to stay. So Germany had been defeated, but the Cold War was beginning, and Greenland is first strategically located in the polar region near the Soviet Union. And so Harry Truman made a cash offer to Denmark of $100 million in gold for the U.S. to annex Greenland and stay on the island. Now, America's era of annexation was sort of wrapping up at this point, and it was a bit out of character for the U.S. to try and acquire territory after World War II. So when Denmark declined the offer, Truman pivoted and instead of acquiring the island, agreed to a military basing agreement. And that was what he'd really wanted anyway, the strategic value of Greenland without actually taking the territory. So they worked out an agreement, and the U.S. uh still has a base in Greenland today and extensive military rights across the island. And so Donald Trump is really the fourth attempt to acquire Greenland. And he he sort of met the same end as Truman. He realized that Denmark's not interested in giving this island up, but maybe America can get what it wants out of Greenland without actually annexing the territory.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

Well, and this is such an expansive look at, you know, all the various ways or all the various places that the US has tried to annex and expand into. So I'm curious, you know, you started a kind of a very small project that you thought, you know, just a map that you were going to throw onto social media. So in in all of your research, what what surprised you?

SPEAKER_01

Aaron Ross Powell The thing that surprised me the most was how many of these annexation stories begin not with American conquest or manifest destiny, but with other territories requesting to become part of the United States. That was some lesser-known history that I discovered. So in the 19th century, during a more turbulent time in Latin America, there were requests from El Salvador, the Yucatan Peninsula, Honduras to become part of the U.S. And one of the most fascinating stories, which I wish people knew about more, was in the 1870s, Ulysses Grant came very close to acquiring the Dominican Republic. So the U.S. had been interested in having a port in the Caribbean for a while. There had been negotiations with the Dominican Republic. But in 1870, Grant reached a deal with uh the Dominican government to annex the entire country, and he brought it to the Senate, and it was a tied vote in the Senate. It required two-thirds to pass, and it was a tie. So it didn't happen. But there was significant support in both the Dominican Republic and the U.S. for bringing the Dominican Republic into the Union. And there were several reasons for this. But Grant's major reason was that after the Civil War, during the turmoil of Reconstruction, he thought that the Dominican Republic as a U.S. state could be a refuge for emancipated African Americans, not as a way of sort of deporting them or forcing them out of the South. But he thought that if there's a black majority state that emancipated people in the South have the option of going to, it would be a refuge from racism. And not only could they move to the Dominican Republic and um live in a freer place, but the threat of them leaving would push Southerners to treat them better. And if there was the possibility of this important part of the Southern economy picking up and moving somewhere else, it would be a way of stopping discrimination against African Americans in the South. So anyone who reads the book isn't going to be surprised that Donald Trump was unsuccessful in acquiring Greenland. So Donald Trump is probably one of America's most ambitious annexationists in terms of his rhetoric, but he's completely failed in actually changing the country's borders at all. And that's not surprising. The structural conditions in 2026 are just not conducive to annexation. So there's the global pushback and the fact that borders are more stable today, and there are international institutions that uh don't want countries to be changing their borders and taking territory. But even more importantly, U.S. annexation has always been very practical. It's not just taking territory for territory's sake. There was usually some sort of motivation for why the U.S. wanted to expand its borders. And in the 20th century, America's leaders realized that they could get what they wanted out of the world without adding territory. And so Trump's Greenland deal is a great example of that. If the U.S. wants basing rights in Greenland, it can negotiate a basing treaty with Greenland and get that military presence without changing the map. So there's just no need for moving borders, for taking territory into the 21st century. America has other ways of expanding. out into the world and increasing its influence without annexation.

SPEAKER_00

And what do you hope readers take away from your book?

SPEAKER_01

The main thing would be that America's borders aren't inevitable. Over the country's 250 year history, a series of choices and events shaped every single one of America's borders. Reasons why, you know, Maine ends where it does and New Brunswick begins where it does. That was hard fought over at the negotiating table. Reasons why after the Spanish-American War, Puerto Rico came under U.S. control, but Cuba didn't. So sometimes these borders were formed by circumstances and by foreign pushback. But often what determined where America's borders would be, what territory it would take, what territory it wouldn't, was different visions of the United States. So for example, after the Mexican-American War, the US was probably militarily capable of annexing all of Mexico. And there was a group in Washington called the All of Mexico movement that wanted just that. But that set off a debate is this going to transform the country from a republic into an empire? Are we going to give citizenship to all of these new Mexican Americans, or are we going to make them second-class citizens or not citizens at all? If Mexicans became citizens, how would that affect domestic politics? So that this was a choice and it was a vision of America that the US would take some Mexican land, but with only a limited number of people and it would give them citizenship because they were few in number. And that's why the southern border is where it is the U.S. took some of the valuable but less populated land and left all of the major cities within Mexico's borders.

SPEAKER_00

And where should people go when they've finished reading your book and they want to learn more about you and the work that you do.

SPEAKER_01

So AmericaButbigger.com is my website and you can listen to all of my podcast appearances and there are so many stories in this book and we've touched on some of the more fascinating ones, but I've got different podcasts that really hone in on, you know, Honduras or El Salvador or wherever. And I I also keep an annexation blog where I connect today's news to America's territorial ambitions in the past. I have a recent post about why have Canada and Mexico never teamed up to counter American expansionism. And I've got some writing that's going to be published soon about a fascinating historical anniversary coming up. November 4th, 2026 is the 40th anniversary of the last time America acquired an inhabited territory. Fun trivia question for your listeners the Northern Mariana Islands came into political union with the U.S. on November 4th, 1986, and it was the last time the U.S. has has annexed a place with a population. So that's an interesting anniversary coming up.

SPEAKER_00

Aaron Ross Powell Yes. Very interesting indeed. And we've only touched on some of this because the the book is chalk full of of anecdotes about the the various methods and and countries and territories that the U.S. has tried to annex so is there anything that we haven't covered that you want future readers to know so I have sort of a request for your listeners.

SPEAKER_01

I've tried to make this book as comprehensive as possible and I've found over 40 countries that the U.S. tried to annex, maybe over 60 depending on on what you count, hundreds and hundreds of stories. But I wouldn't be surprised at all if with America's vast annexation ambitions, maybe there's a story or two that I've missed. So if anyone reads the book and knows about some adventurer or scheme or purchase attempt, I would love to hear about it. So if anyone wants to go to americabutbigger.com and contact me I want to collect all of these different annexation stories because hopefully they'll they'll be of interest or of use to anyone researching America's territorial expansions in the future.

SPEAKER_00

Well there you go there's your call to action folks.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah it's it's a challenge really you know I don't have any stories in in the book about India or Germany or Tanzania probably because there aren't any but if you know if you know of an American annexation attempt anywhere around the world that I haven't covered please reach out.

SPEAKER_00

I love it. Well and on that note to the readers out there America but bigger is available in bookstores now so be sure to pick up your copy. Thank you again Mark.

SPEAKER_01

Thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_00

My thanks again to Mark for spending his time with me America but Bigger can be found in bookstores now and provides a fascinating history of attempted US territorial expansion thanks peeps. I'll see you next time as I explored this chapter of American history. If you liked what you heard be sure to subscribe and share with your friends. I look forward to our next cup of coffee together